Cream City Brick Myths Jailhouse West Bend Wisconsin 1886
In Categories: ,

2 Cream City Brick Myths That Every Historic Building Owner Needs to Know

If you think that Cream City bricks were made only in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, then we’ve got news for you: that thought is completely wrong.

Today’s post will shed light on Cream City brick. We will reveal the 2 common myths about the beloved Cream City bricks. So let’s dive in! 

Myth #1 – Only Made in Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Popular understanding of the famed Cream City brick was that it all started in Milwaukee, Wisconsin, way back in and around 1835-36. Early brickmakers mined a red clay and a blue clay, mixed them together, and burned it, producing a buff color. Presto!

While this is a super over-simplification of the process, the beautiful creamy brick became associated with Milwaukee. And leading up to the American Civil War in the 1850s, Milwaukee started mass producing this type of brick, which went hand-and-hand with a building boom. 

Post Civil War, Milwaukee brickmakers industrialized. Technology propelled the mass production of Cream City brick. One of the more famous brick manufacturers, Burnham Brothers, patented a first steam-powered brick machine sometime in the 1850s. Later in 1867, the Burnham Brothers improved their machine and updated their patent.

Cream City Brick Myths Burnham Brothers Manufacturing in Milwaukee
Cream city brick manufacturing machine in 1867 for the Burnham Brothers Manufacturing in Milwaukee, Wisconsin
Cream City Brick Myths Burnham Brothers Manufacturing in Milwaukee View 2
Cream city brick manufacturing machine in 1867 for the Burnham Brothers Manufacturing in Milwaukee, Wisconsin alternative view

The next several decades saw a huge increase in production, use, and media coverage of the Cream City brick. Speaking of media coverage, that was when the great debate started over the name. Because Milwaukee had so many buffed colored buildings, several names surfaced through newspapers and personal accounts. Names included:

  • Milwaukee Brick
  • Cream City of the lakes
  • Cream City of the West
  • Cream Colored City
  • Cream City

Ultimately, Cream City stuck, and did it ever. Sports teams, advertisements, and even companies “borrowed” Cream City to incorporate in their names. For example, the 19th century Germantown Lime Company, based in Germantown, Wisconsin, changed its name to Cream City Lime Company to better market its products via name association. 

But what about the myth that it was only made in Milwaukee? 

All of the neighboring counties of Milwaukee, in fact, had Cream City brick operations. But so did areas along the coast of Lake Michigan (as far north as Green Bay, Wisconsin) and the coast of Lake Superior (around Bayfield, Wisconsin). 

Away from the Great Lakes, Cream City bricks were produced as far west as Baraboo, Monroe, and Waupaca, and most places in between. For example, Washington County, Wisconsin is the county where we (The Tower Heritage Center) is based. Between 1853 and 1903, Washington County, Wisconsin was home to 6 brick factories at one time or another, located in West Bend, Farmington, Boltonville, Kewaskum, Barton, Polk, and Schleisingerville (now known as Slinger).

Cream City Brick Myths Slinger Wisconsin Brick Yard 1892
Cream city brick myth #1 wrong in a brick yard in 1892 in Slinger, Wisconsin

In sum, Cream City bricks were indeed not exclusive to Milwaukee.

Myth #2 – Only Made in Wisconsin (period!)

So if not Milwaukee, then definitely Wisconsin only…right?

Sorry, but nope. Wrong again.

Buffy, creamy, yellow bricks can be found as early as the mid 1600s in Holland. That’s right, Holland! And a few other European countries, such as Germany and the British Isles.

During the height of Cream City brick manufacturing in Wisconsin, production was also happening in parts of Canada, mostly around the Toronto region. In fact, Cream City bricks can be found in 13 other states besides Wisconsin. 

It was truly far from being only made in Wisconsin.

Parting Words

There you have it. 2 myths about Cream City brick. You may have never even realized that this beloved brick had a deeper story.

So while Cream City brick is deeply connected to Milwaukee and Wisconsin’s history, but not exclusively, it is still a valuable commodity worth preserving

And speaking of history worth saving, join The Tower Heritage Center’s mailing list and sign up as a member TODAY. Your support helps preserve the history of not only Cream City brick, but also the broader stories around the industries, innovation, and lives of our past.

You Make Our Work Possible!

Community support allows us to continue telling Washington County’s stories. We invite you to become a member and consider making an additional gift of support. Contact us about sponsorship opportunities for local businesses as well.